Welcome to the Threat Hunter Blog

Observations from out on the rim...

Active Defense

Dr. Peter Stephenson

I'll begin by announcing our new sponsor, Intel471.  Intel471 is a threat actor-centered service that has a database of over a million threat actors and that tracks actors through participation in the underground forums where the hackers do their work and sell their warez.  Click on the link below to visit their web site.Welcome to the Threat Hunter Blog!

An interesting story came across my desk this week – the topic was active defense or, in the vernacular, “hack-back”.  I found this interesting because it seems so controversial and I really don’t understand why.  Before we explore this a bit deeper and I tell you my position on it (you may or may not agree – that’s your prerogative) let’s just get the facts out of the way.  First, in the U.S. it’s illegal and second, more often than not it simply does not work.  When it does work it’s because you were amazingly lucky or very, very skilled.  That certainly narrows the probability for success. 

So if active defense is illegal and unreliable, why would anyone do it? Two answers come to mind: revenge and greed. 

On the revenge side it must feel good to get inside the server of the twerp who just sent a bot into your system through a phishing email.  “I got that sucker… he won’t come after me again!”  Think again… the stories of the hackers turning back on folks who hack back are legion. 

This is Stephenson’s Theory of Rattlesnakes.  If you are stupid enough to pick up one – and it doesn’t bite you – you can’t just put it down.  If you do you’re toast.  The snake will turn on you and now it’s really mad.  You have to fling the snake as far from you as you can.  Same with hack-back.  If you go after the hackers you’d better be prepared for retaliation ‘cause that snake now is really angry.

Now we come to greed.  There are several consultancies – usually boutiques – that specialize in active defense.  They get good money for breaking the law. There is no lack of clients, either.  One consultant who does this told the author of the story:

“It has been attack after attack after attack. My business has skyrocketed. I feel like I should send the Chinese a Christmas card saying thank you for a wonderful year.”

The story that got me thinking about this, (http://www.pymnts.com/in-depth/2015/attacking-hackers-the-next-security-frontier/#/Vco7407D_bU), talks about the “three As” of active defense: annoy, attribution and attack.  Annoy, as the author of this piece describes it is really nothing more than a honeypot. That is useful for research but I fail to see how it would annoy the attacker beyond getting frustrated by not finding anything of value and being led down a rabbit-hole. There’s nothing illegal about this and you may learn something that would allow competent authority to take down the server.

Attribution is the hardest problem in cyber attacks. ADHD has an app called Honey Badger that uses geolocation to pinpoint attackers.  I have not tried it, I have no idea at this pont how – or even if – it works. The other way, of course, is beacons.  These are tokens that are inserted in data that the hacker wants to steal and that reports its true destination.

At this point I must say that so far I would only expect to be successful against script kiddies.  The real bad guys are writing good software (or really bad, depending upon your viewpoint) and the cyber crooks are buying/renting and using it.  There’s a full-blown underground economy here, but that’s a story for another time.

The third piece, obviously, is attack.  This is a bad idea.  It’s illegal (I already said that but it bears repeating) and you are more likely to nuke some computer that belongs to a mom-and-pop store and has been pwned by the bad guys than you are to hit the bad guys themselves.

So, what’s the point?  Can’t answer that, really… I suppose it just feels good… but so does stopping when you’ve been smacking your head against a brick wall.
 


<< Back Add New Comment
PeterMaype
10/18/2017 4:01:38 PM
legs
d <a href= http://paydayrgd.com/mesa-financial-payday-loans >payday loans direct lenders only no teletrack</a> otherwise
more <a href=http://paydayrgd.com/payday-loans-in-delaware>best online payday loans instant approval</a>
castle payday loans review
CialisUrill
10/18/2017 3:50:07 PM
lseemse
p <a href= http://cialisxtl.com/how-to-get-cialis-prescription >how quickly does cialis work</a> been
hall <a href=http://cialisxtl.com/cialis-10mg-daily>cialis without a prescription</a>
cialis online canada
Lloydowege
10/18/2017 3:44:48 PM
ijourney
e <a href= http://erectionpillsvcl.com/viagra-para-mujeres >viagra discounts</a> believed
much <a href=http://erectionpillsvcl.com>viagra online usa</a>
buying viagra without a prescription
Cialisavamp
10/18/2017 3:44:37 PM
tbesidesv
z <a href= http://cialisxtl.com/what-is-cialis-good-for >5 mg cialis</a> tone
forth <a href=http://cialisxtl.com/cialis-no-prescription>cialis before and after</a>
how many mg of cialis should i take
CialisUrill
10/18/2017 3:20:09 PM
rreadp
u <a href= http://cialisxtl.com/when-will-cialis-be-available-over-the-counter >cialis 100mg</a> spoke
going <a href=http://cialisxtl.com/how-to-use-cialis-20mg>cialis best price</a>
is there a generic drug for cialis
Lloydowege
10/18/2017 3:16:19 PM
wpassing
t <a href= http://erectionpillsvcl.com/max-viagra-dosage >purchase viagra</a> ma'am
evening <a href=http://erectionpillsvcl.com>viagra alternative gnc</a>
how much viagra to take
Cialisavamp
10/18/2017 3:15:25 PM
kpastd
c <a href= http://cialisxtl.com/when-does-the-patent-on-cialis-expire >cialis without a prescription</a> opinion
society <a href=http://cialisxtl.com/cialis-cost-walgreens>daily cialis dose</a>
how does cialis work
PeterMaype
10/18/2017 2:50:50 PM
closed
b <a href= http://paydayrgd.com/payday-loans-thornton-co >ace payday loans locations</a> hill
will <a href=http://paydayrgd.com/payday-loans-fresno>maryland payday loans</a>
too many payday loans consolidation
CialisUrill
10/18/2017 2:49:51 PM
mhopez
o <a href= http://cialisxtl.com/daily-cialis >how to get cialis for free</a> die
note <a href=http://cialisxtl.com/best-online-pharmacy-for-generic-cialis>cialis 5mg daily</a>
cheap cialis
Lloydowege
10/18/2017 2:48:00 PM
mwell
m <a href= http://erectionpillsvcl.com/viagra-commercial-asian >viagra mechanism of action</a> silent
according <a href=http://erectionpillsvcl.com/cost-of-viagra-without-insurance>best online pharmacy viagra</a>
herb viagra
PeterMaype
10/18/2017 2:27:12 PM
wish
b <a href= http://paydayrgd.com/new-year-payday-loans >payday loans oakland ca</a> friend
touched <a href=http://paydayrgd.com/payday-loans-in-augusta-ga>payday loans las vegas nv</a>
payday loans bad credit online
CialisUrill
10/18/2017 2:19:40 PM
ytearsk
w <a href= http://cialisxtl.com/is-cialis-covered-by-insurance >when is the best time to take cialis</a> smile
I'm <a href=http://cialisxtl.com/online-generic-cialis>is cialis over the counter</a>
cialis daily dosage
Lloydowege
10/18/2017 2:19:20 PM
dneck
z <a href= http://erectionpillsvcl.com >viagra canada</a> lying
die <a href=http://erectionpillsvcl.com/does-viagra-work>buying viagra in canada</a>
viagra for kids
Cialisavamp
10/18/2017 2:15:47 PM
nrisingy
w <a href= http://cialisxtl.com/cialis-cost-without-insurance >cialis 30 day free trial coupon</a> expression
notice <a href=http://cialisxtl.com/cialis-canada-prices>cialis heartburn</a>
samples of cialis
PeterMaype
10/18/2017 2:03:48 PM
since
a <a href= http://paydayrgd.com/california-payday-loans >green circle payday loans</a> perfectly
dare <a href=http://paydayrgd.com/second-chance-payday-loans>non payday loans for bad credit</a>
online payday loans direct lenders only
Lloydowege
10/18/2017 1:50:39 PM
eleaving
s <a href= http://erectionpillsvcl.com/viagra-stock >compro viagra</a> just
directly <a href=http://erectionpillsvcl.com/viagra-for-sale-cheap>viagra versus cialis</a>
viagra commercial model
CialisUrill
10/18/2017 1:49:06 PM
jbreakfasts
z <a href= http://cialisxtl.com/cialis-professional >cialis daily use</a> captain
sense <a href=http://cialisxtl.com/where-can-i-buy-cialis-over-the-counter>viagra vs cialis vs levitra reviews</a>
over the counter cialis walmart
Cialisavamp
10/18/2017 1:45:52 PM
idirectlyw
c <a href= http://cialisxtl.com/alternatives-to-cialis-and-viagra >cialis 5mg</a> whom
gentleman <a href=http://cialisxtl.com/how-long-does-cialis-work>cialis cost walgreens</a>
when to take cialis 20 mg
PeterMaype
10/18/2017 1:40:03 PM
might
v <a href= http://paydayrgd.com/payday-loans-in-delaware >online payday loans with no credit check</a> scene
rich <a href=http://paydayrgd.com/payday-loans-greensboro-nc>statute of limitations on payday loans</a>
payday loans albuquerque nm
Lloydowege
10/18/2017 1:21:58 PM
bothers
p <a href= http://erectionpillsvcl.com/viagra-heart-attack >viagra experiences first time</a> showed
unless <a href=http://erectionpillsvcl.com/can-i-buy-viagra-online>free viagra samples by mail</a>
how long does viagra stay in your system
25370 items total 1  2  3  4  5  ...  1269 
Add New Comment
Name*
Subject*
Comment*
Please type the confirmation code you see on the image*
Reload image